Product
Firmness
Score
Product
Firmness
Score
Puffy vs. Casper Mattress Comparison
If you’re looking for a new mattress but can’t seem to seal the deal, the Puffy and Casper mattresses are great options. We’ll guide you about its sizing and price, mattress construction, and its different benefits and features to help you decide on the right choice. Check out what others are saying about our testing methodology.
Puffy vs. Casper Overview
The Casper and Puffy are both all-foam mattresses with simple three-layer constructions. The Casper has a plush, latex-like top layer, a memory foam transition layer, and a supportive foam base layer. The Puffy features gel-infused memory foam above two high-density polyfoam layers.
| Puffy is best for… | Casper is best for… |
| Side sleepers | Back sleepers |
| Average-weight back sleepers | Couples |
| Those who sleep warm, but love memory foam | Those with back pain |
Who Should Choose the Puffy Mattress?
- Side sleepers: The Puffy is ideal for those who sleep on their sides thanks to good spinal alignment and pressure relief.
- Average-weight back sleepers: The Puffy is great for those who sleep on their back and will appreciate the balanced feel that the Puffy offers.
- Those who sleep warm, but love memory foam: The Puffy provides comfortable cooling.
Who Should Choose the Casper Mattress?
- Back sleepers: The Casper offers a balanced combination of cushioning and whole-body support for back sleepers.
- Couples: The Casper is ideal for couples since they are unlikely to experience disruptions related to motion transfer, thanks to absorbent foam layers.
- Those with back pain: The Casper provides extra lumbar support from the zoned transition layer.
Puffy vs. Casper Mattress Video Comparison
Watch me and Corey test the Puffy and Casper in this video comparison. We go over its mattress similarities and differences, firmness and feel, as well as the various suitable sleep positions of Puffy and Casper.
Puffy vs. Casper: Top Similarities
- Pricing: The pricing for the Casper and Puffy is similar, a Queen size bed from either mattress brand costs around $1,100.
- Spine alignment: Both beds keep your spine aligned, which can help reduce muscle soreness.
- Construction: Both of these mattresses utilize memory foam, which gives the bed a supportive, contouring surface.
Puffy vs. Casper: Top Differences
- Responsiveness: The Casper is slightly more responsive than the Puffy, probably because AirScape foam is designed to mimic the buoyancy of latex foam. If you are looking for a responsive mattress, see our list of the best latex mattresses.
- Pressure relief: The Puffy provides better pressure relief around your shoulders and hips.
- Motion transfer: The Casper minimizes motion transfer better than the Puffy, though both performed well in this category.
- Temperature: The Puffy stays a little cooler because of the gel-infused foam at the top of the mattress.
Puffy vs. Casper: Firmness & Feel Differences
Firmness and feel are big factors to consider when choosing the right bed for you. In this section, we’ll discuss the firmness and feel difference of the Puffy and the Casper.
What’s the Firmness Of the Puffy & Casper Mattresses?
We consider the Puffy and Casper mattresses both to be medium-firm, or about 6/10 on the firmness scale. They each have a soft top layer and a firmer second layer, so the mattresses feel soft at first contact, but get firmer the further down you sink.
What Do the Puffy & Casper Mattresses Feel Like?
It is easy to move around in the Puffy, making it a good choice for combination sleepers who move around at night. To add, its three-layer foam construction gives you a soft and supportive feel rather than feeling “stuck.” On the other hand, the Casper’s comfort layer is a plush and responsive polyfoam that brings immediate comfort and light contouring that works well for back, stomach, and side sleepers.
What’s It Like to Sleep On the Puffy & Casper Mattresses?
The Puffy mattress is an excellent choice for side sleepers who want pressure relief and a gentle hug around the hips and shoulders. Meanwhile, lightweight and average-weight people are well supported on the Casper no matter their sleeping position, however, heavier folks are not as good of a fit.
The Puffy vs. Casper Mattresses By Body Type
Puffy Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:
| Body Type: | BACK SLEEPERS | STOMACH SLEEPERS | SIDE SLEEPERS |
| Lightweight (< 130 lbs): | 4 | 3 | 5 |
| Average-weight (130–230 lbs): | 3 | 3 | 4 |
| Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): | 2 | 2 | 3 |
Casper Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:
| Body Type: | BACK SLEEPERS | STOMACH SLEEPERS | SIDE SLEEPERS |
| Lightweight (< 130 lbs): | 5 | 4 | 4 |
| Average-weight (130–230 lbs): | 5 | 3 | 5 |
| Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): | 3 | 2 | 2 |
1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent
Average-Weight Sleepers (130–230 lbs)
Average-weight back sleepers and side sleepers will find the Casper a suitable choice thanks to its medium-firm mattress and optimal support that aligns the neck and spine. Similarly, the Puffy provides great pressure relief for average-weight side sleepers, especially those who prefer a feel of a gentle hug around the hips and shoulders.
Heavyweight Sleepers (> 230 lbs)
Heavyweight stomach sleepers may experience uncomfortable sinkage in the Casper mattress. We also do not find the Puffy mattress to be supportive enough for heavyweight side sleepers and back sleepers.
Lightweight Sleepers (< 130 lbs)
Lightweight side sleepers should get the lower back support they need on the Puffy mattress—the upper layers of the Puffy will cradle pressure points and conform around the natural curves of the body. Additionally, the Casper mattress should provide great comfort no matter the sleeping position, making them a great choice for lightweight combination sleepers.
Differences In Mattress Construction
The Puffy and Casper are all-foam mattresses. In this section, you’ll learn about its multiple layers and materials, including their height differences.
| Puffy Mattress Materials | Casper Mattress Materials |
| Polyester cover | Recycled polyester |
| Cooling Gel Cloud foam | AirScape foam |
| Climate-Adaptive foam | Zoned Support foam |
| Firm Core Support foam | Base foam |
| “10” | “11” |
Cover
The Puffy’s cover consists of polyester that is cool to the touch. Similarly, the Casper mattress is wrapped in a soft, stretchy polyester cover.
Comfort Layers
The Puffy boasts two inches of Cooling Cloud foam with gel infusions—a layer that is meant to pull heat away from your body and promote airflow. The Casper’s comfort layer features an AirScape foam, which is soft, buoyant, and perforated for added breathability.
Support Layers
With six inches of Firm Core foam support layer, the Puffy mattress ensures added structure and durability to the mattress. On the other hand, the Casper is designed with a durable and dense polyurethane foam support layer that brings excellent cushion and motion isolation.
Puffy vs. Casper Pricing
| Size | Puffy Prices | Casper Prices |
| Twin | $1949.00 | $895.00 |
| Twin XL | $2099.00 | $995.00 |
| Full | $2249.00 | $1195.00 |
| Queen | $2399.00 | $1295.00 |
| King | $2599.00 | $1695.00 |
| California King | $2599.00 | $1695.00 |
For exclusive discounts on both beds see our Puffy mattress coupons and Casper mattress coupons.
Puffy vs. Casper Mattress Performance Ratings & Differences
The Puffy 3.4/5
The Puffy is a three-layer foam mattress made with cooling gel-infused memory foam and motion-isolating base foams. It has a medium-firm feel that blends contouring support with cushioning comfort.
The Casper 4.8/5
The Casper mattress is an all-foam bed that pairs plush polyfoam with Zoned Support memory foam for excellent pressure relief and body alignment. The Casper provides comfort for back, stomach, side, and combination sleepers who weigh less than 230 lbs, and its motion isolation makes it good for couples.
Temperature
Both mattresses feature elements that bring the foam to a more neutral temperature. Specifically, Puffy’s comfort layer is infused with gel, and the Casper top layer is perforated with tiny channels that improve airflow.
Motion Transfer
All-foam mattresses do a great job of isolating motion at its source. You’ll notice very little movement spreading from one end of the bed to the other, especially on the Casper.
Edge Support
Neither the Casper nor the Puffy has any special edge support features, but we think they both keep you fairly well supported. With that said, we noticed a little more sinkage along the edges of the Puffy.
Pressure Relief
Casper delivers pressure relief particularly well near the head and foot of the bed, thanks to Zoned Support in its memory foam transition layer. The Puffy may feel a little firmer at first, but it softens up quite a bit the longer you lie on the mattress surface.
Pain Relief
The Puffy evenly distributes the weight of back sleepers, particularly those weighing under 130 lbs, so they shouldn’t develop new back pain on the mattress. With a soft comfort layer that cushions the body and a Zoned Support transition layer, the Casper is designed to keep the spine properly supported in every sleeping position.
Durability
The Casper mattress comes with a 10-year warranty, and the Puffy has a Lifetime warranty for the original owner.
Shipping, Returns, & Warranties
Puffy
Puffy customers in the contiguous U.S. get free shipping and delivery within one to three business days. After delivery, your 101-night trial period begins and includes free returns and a full refund (minus shipping). The Puffy Lifetime warranty lasts for the entire period of ownership for the original buyer.
Casper
Casper customers get free bed-in-a-box shipping for new mattress orders in the U.S. and Canada. The 100-night sleep trial starts when your mattress is delivered. The Casper mattress warranty lasts for 10 years and protects against indentations over 1″ deep, cracks or splits in the foam, and broken zippers.
More Puffy Mattresses
Puffy Lux Hybrid Mattress
The Puffy Lux Hybrid is a top choice for side and back sleepers who want a plush, cloud-like sleep experienced, but it’s less-than-ideal for stomach sleepers, who will experience too much sinking in the hips.
Product Details
Material
Hybrid
Firmness
Medium-soft: 5/10
Sleep Trial
101 nights
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Shipping
Free shipping
Price
$$$$$
Our Recommendation
We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:
Side Sleepers
This bed offers pressure relief at both the shoulders and hips, making it a great fit for side sleepers.
Back Sleepers
This bed’s strong support is ideal for back sleepers because it helps keep the spine neutrally aligned.
Hot Sleepers
This bed features extra cooling technology, making it great for hot sleepers.
Back Pain
This bed is a good match for anyone struggling with back pain, as it cushions the lumbar region and has enough support to keep the spine neutrally aligned.
Couples
This bed has great motion isolation so you will not feel your partner tossing and turning at night.
Financing Options
Financing options are available for this mattress.
Puffy Royal Hybrid Mattress
The Puffy Royal Hybrid is Puffy’s take on a luxury memory foam hybrid mattress. Its medium-soft firmness level and conforming top layers make it ideal for side sleepers who like a neutral all-foam feel.
Product Details
Material
Hybrid
Firmness
Medium-soft: 4/10
Sleep Trial
101 nights
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Shipping
Free shipping
Price
$$$$$
Our Recommendation
We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:
Side Sleepers
This bed offers pressure relief at both the shoulders and hips, making it a great fit for side sleepers.
Back Sleepers
This bed’s strong support is ideal for back sleepers because it helps keep the spine neutrally aligned.
Back Pain
This bed is a good match for anyone struggling with back pain, as it cushions the lumbar region and has enough support to keep the spine neutrally aligned.
Couples
This bed has great motion isolation so you will not feel your partner tossing and turning at night.
Financing Options
Financing options are available for this mattress.
More Casper Mattresses
Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress
Extra plush foam makes this Casper’s softest hybrid mattress yet. With seven zones of specialized support, this mattress is not too plush, and your spine should stay aligned all night. The cradling comfort foam combines with two layers of perforated cooling foam that promotes air flow and prevents heat trapping.
Product Details
Material
Hybrid
Firmness
Medium-soft: 4/10
Sleep Trial
100 nights
Warranty
10-year limited warranty
Shipping
Free shipping
Price
$$$$$
Our Recommendation
We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:
Back Sleepers
This bed’s strong support is ideal for back sleepers because it helps keep the spine neutrally aligned.
Stomach Sleepers
This mattress is ideal for stomach sleepers as its firm support promotes spinal alignment.
Back Pain
This bed is a good match for anyone struggling with back pain, as it cushions the lumbar region and has enough support to keep the spine neutrally aligned.
Seniors
This bed is perfect for senior sleepers, as it provides them support and easy mobility.
Financing Options
Financing options are available for this mattress.
Casper Hybrid Mattress
Striking the perfect balance between the contour of memory foam and the bounce of pocket-coils, the Casper Hybrid offers the best of both worlds when it comes to superior comfort and support.
Product Details
Material
Hybrid
Firmness
Medium-soft: 5.5/10
Sleep Trial
100 nights
Warranty
10-year limited warranty
Shipping
Free shipping
Price
$$$$$
Our Recommendation
We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:
Hot Sleepers
This bed features extra cooling technology, making it great for hot sleepers.
Back Pain
This bed is a good match for anyone struggling with back pain, as it cushions the lumbar region and has enough support to keep the spine neutrally aligned.
Seniors
This bed is perfect for senior sleepers, as it provides them support and easy mobility.
Financing Options
Financing options are available for this mattress.
Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress
The Casper Wave Hybrid strikes a balance with a middle-of-the-road firmness level and features that make it appropriate for sleepers of all shapes and sizes. It’s an excellent choice for those who enjoy the Original Casper’s balance of conforming support but want more bounce.
Product Details
Material
Hybrid
Firmness
Medium-soft: 5/10
Sleep Trial
100 nights
Warranty
10-year limited warranty
Shipping
Free shipping
Price
$$$$$
Our Recommendation
We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:
Side Sleepers
This bed offers pressure relief at both the shoulders and hips, making it a great fit for side sleepers.
Back Sleepers
This bed’s strong support is ideal for back sleepers because it helps keep the spine neutrally aligned.
Back Pain
This bed is a good match for anyone struggling with back pain, as it cushions the lumbar region and has enough support to keep the spine neutrally aligned.
Seniors
This bed is perfect for senior sleepers, as it provides them support and easy mobility.
Financing Options
Financing options are available for this mattress.
Casper Element Mattress
The Casper Element is not fancy. It features three memory foam layers, one each designed for comfort, support, and stability. Casper says all three are also breathable and able to release heat.
Product Details
Material
Foam
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6/10
Sleep Trial
100 nights
Warranty
10-year limited warranty
Shipping
Free shipping
Price
$$$$$
Our Recommendation
We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:
Side Sleepers
This bed offers pressure relief at both the shoulders and hips, making it a great fit for side sleepers.
Back Sleepers
This bed’s strong support is ideal for back sleepers because it helps keep the spine neutrally aligned.
Seniors
This bed is perfect for senior sleepers, as it provides them support and easy mobility.
Financing Options
Financing options are available for this mattress.
Still Looking? Be sure to check out our other mattress comparisons:
- Casper vs. Amerisleep
- Casper vs. Bear
- Casper vs. Brooklyn Bedding
- Casper vs. GhostBed
- Casper vs. Helix
- Casper vs. Layla
- Casper vs. Leesa
- Casper vs. Loom & Leaf
- Casper vs. Lull
- Casper vs. Nectar
- Casper vs. Purple
- Casper vs. Saatva
- Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic
- Casper vs. Tuft & Needle
- Casper vs. WinkBeds
- Casper Nova Hybrid vs. Layla Hybrid
- Casper Mattress Alternatives
- Puffy vs. Leesa
- Puffy vs. Lull
- Puffy vs. Nectar
- Puffy vs. Nolah
- Puffy vs. Purple
- Puffy vs. Saatva
- Puffy vs. WinkBeds
Our Final Take
Both the Casper and Puffy mattresses are all-foam, made to suit most sleep positions, and offer advanced cooling. If you’re a side, back, or combination sleeper looking for a more budget-friendly mattress, we think the Casper Original mattress might work for you. However, if you’re a stomach sleeper who wants extra support, we recommend the Puffy mattress instead.
Puffy & Casper FAQs
Do I need to flip the Puffy mattress?
No. The Puffy mattress is intentionally built with layers that provide maximum support and comfort. Flipping the mattress would defeat this purpose since the dense support layer would be on top. If concerned with wear, rotating the mattress every three to six months would suffice.
Do Casper mattresses sag over time?
Made from three layers of foam, the Casper mattress may soften and sag slightly over time, like other foam mattresses on the market. To avoid this, we recommend specific lightweight and average-weight side sleepers to use the Casper as they are less prone to significant pressure.
Is Puffy good for side sleepers?
Yes. The Puffy mattress will be enjoyed by average-weight and light-weight side sleepers thanks to its excellent pressure relieving and spine alignment properties. Plus, the cooling gel-infused memory foam makes this medium-firm bed comfy and supportive—an ideal choice for any side sleeper out there.
