Best Plush Mattress Toppers
A plush mattress topper can be a helpful alternative to splurging on a new mattress, adding a layer of softness and even specific benefits like pressure relief or cooling properties. Read on for a rundown of eight of the best plush mattress toppers for a better night’s sleep.
Best Plush Mattress Topper
- Nolah Mattress Topper: Editor’s Pick
- Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper: Best Organic Mattress Topper
- Coop Home Goods Retreat Mattress Topper: Best Mattress Topper for Bigger Beds
- Parachute Home Down Mattress Topper: Best Down Mattress Topper
- ViscoSoft Pillow Top Memory Foam Topper: Best Hybrid Mattress Topper
- Dreamfoam Mattress Topper 2″ Gel Swirl: Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- Brooklinen Down Alternative Mattress Topper: Best Down Alternative Mattress Topper
- Helix Plush Mattress Topper: Best Mattress Topper for Allergies
Nolah Mattress Topper
Editor’s Pick
Nolah Mattress Topper
The Nolah mattress topper is designed to reduce pressure points and comes with a generous 10-year warranty.
Mattress Nerd Score
4.90 / 5
Nolah’s mattress topper is made with two inches of cooling, pressure-relieving AirFoam, a patented memory foam that promises not to trap heat. The plush version of the topper offers deep contouring and extra pressure relief in the hip and shoulder area, making it a great pick for side sleepers in particular.
Reason to Buy: Memory foam can tend to get too hot, but Nolah’s mattress topper is specifically designed to promote airflow. Its unique memory foam is also meant to last longer than a traditional foam would. This is a great option for anyone looking to add a cooling layer of softness that doesn’t skimp on support.
Elastic bands on all four corners keep the Nolah topper in place. It’s designed to fit mattresses between 10″ and 15″ in height.
Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper
Best Organic Mattress Topper
Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper
This non-toxic topper is perfect for back sleepers thanks to its latex layer.
Mattress Nerd Score
4.70 / 5
Birch wraps layers of wool and Talalay latex in an organic cotton cover to make a non-toxic and sustainable topper. It adds a plush, pressure-relieving layer that also maximizes airflow.
Reason to Buy: Two inches of organic materials with GREENGUARD Gold and GOTS certifications offer a balance of plushness and deep contouring in this topper. The cotton, wool, and natural latex are naturally breathable and temperature neutral, so it’s a great option for hot sleepers.
Give it a test run with Birch’s 100-night sleep trial.
Coop Home Goods Retreat Mattress Topper
Best Mattress Topper for Bigger Beds
Coop Retreat Mattress Topper
This mattress topper offers a plush layer of CertiPUR-US and GREENGUARD Gold-certified memory foam fill.
Mattress Nerd Score
4.90 / 5
The Retreat Mattress Topper from Coop is made with CertiPUR-US and GREENGUARD Gold-certified memory foam in a baffle box construction for even support and cushioning.
Reason to Buy: The Retreat topper may look like a plush down comforter, but the construction ensures the cross-cut foam/microfiber blend–what Coop calls its Oomph memory foam fill– stays evenly distributed across your bed for maximum comfort. The hypoallergenic filler adds softness, support, and a boost of breathability to any mattress.
Note that the Retreat is only available in queen and king sizes.
Parachute Home Down Mattress Topper
Best Down Mattress Topper
Parachute Down Mattress Topper
The Parachute Down Feather Bed is a soft, fluffy mattress topper that’s a great match for hot sleepers and back sleepers.
Mattress Nerd Score
4.30 / 5
Read Full ReviewParachute’s luxurious feather bed is hypoallergenic with a cushy soft feel. The three-inch topper has a dual-chamber design with baffle box stitching for even distribution.
Reason to Buy: Premium European white down in a sateen cotton shell gives this mattress topper an ultra-plush feel. It adds a little luxury–and a lot of softness–to any mattress.
Parachute’s topper, with its five-star hotel feel, is available in sizes from twin to California king.
ViscoSoft Serene Hybrid Memory Foam Topper
Best Hybrid Mattress Topper
ViscoSoft Serene Hybrid Mattress Topper
This topper features down alternative and gel-infused memory foam for a feel that’s the best of both worlds.
This four-inch mattress topper is made with a 2.5-inch layer of CertiPUR-US-certified memory foam beneath 1.5 inches of down alternative for support and softness.
Reason to Buy: The hybrid construction of the Serene topper from Viscosoft makes it both supportive and comfortable. Each topper has a 300-thread count pillow-top cover featuring the breathable luxury of an airy down alternative over the contouring memory foam layer.
The cover has adjustable straps and a fully-elastic skirt to keep everything in place, and it can be removed and machine washed for easy cleaning.
Dreamfoam 2” Gel Swirl Memory Foam Topper
Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Dreamfoam 2″ Gel Swirl Memory Foam Mattress Topper
For those in search of a softer mattress, without the price tag of a new one, the DreamFoam 2″ Gel Swirl Memory Foam Topper could be the solution for you.
Mattress Nerd Score
4.50 / 5
Read Full ReviewTwo inches of cooling gel-infused memory foam make this a contouring, gently responsive topper for serious pressure point relief.
Reason to Buy: The patented gel memory foam in this topper has an ultra-plush feel that sleeps cool and contours deeply to relieve pressure in the shoulders, hips, and anywhere else you might be feeling aches and pains. It’s not fancy, just a cooling layer of CertiPUR-US-certified foam, but what more do you need?
This well-reviewed topper is available in a wide range of sizes.
Brooklinen Down Alternative Mattress Topper
Best Down Alternative Mattress Topper
Brooklinen Down Alternative Mattress Topper
The Brooklinen Down Alternative Mattress Topper features evenly distributed microgel for a soft sleep surface.
This topper is made with ultra-soft microgel, which adds a luxuriously cushioning feel to any mattress. A tufted construction ensures even distribution all night.
Reason to Buy: The microgel in Brooklinen’s down alternative topper is soft and silky, designed to add softness without adding heat. A waterproof barrier at the bottom protects your mattress without the telltale sound of other waterproof covers. Plus, the generously-sized skirt means this topper fits mattresses up to 18 inches in height.
This Brooklinen topper starts at a full size, so it won’t be a good fit for a twin bed.
Helix Plush Mattress Topper
Best Mattress Topper for Allergies
Helix Plush Mattress Topper
This plush topper provides a cushy layer that can make firm mattresses feel softer.
Mattress Nerd Score
4.40 / 5
This plush mattress topper from Helix is made with a hypoallergenic fiberfill that’s soft and silky, making it a great pick for those with allergies.
Reason to Buy: The fiber clusters in this topper add 1.5 inches of breathable softness. The baffle box stitching creates pockets of fill to minimize clumping and offer high loft night after night. The 15″ skirt is designed to accommodate most mattresses, and the whole topper is machine-washable.
Not sure if this is the topper of your dreams? Helix offers a 100-night trial so you can see for yourself.
Considerations for a Plush Mattress Topper
There are a lot of benefits to medium-firm or firm mattresses, but you may find yourself missing that pillow-y plushness. A plush mattress topper is a great way to make your mattress softer, without sacrificing the support your firmer mattress offers. Here’s what to keep in mind as you shop for a plush mattress topper.
Materials
Toppers come in a range of materials, from latex and memory foam to down and down alternatives. No matter which you find most appealing, it’s smart to opt for high-quality in both material and construction. That will ensure long-term durability.
Pressure Relief
If you’re looking to relieve pressure point pain in your hips and shoulders, memory foam and latex toppers will be your best bet. These materials contour closely to the curves of your body, which can help alleviate stress and promote proper spinal alignment to help minimize back pain.
Cooling Benefits
Overheating at night can be a real detriment to deep sleep, so some toppers are specifically designed for cooler, more comfortable nights. If you want a plush topper that’s also cooling, look for gel-infused memory foam or naturally temperature-neutral latex. Other natural materials, like wool and cotton, can also boost breathability and help promote airflow.
Sleeping Position
How you spend most of the night will play a big role in how comfortable and supportive you find a particular mattress topper. Stomach sleepers in particular will benefit from a firmer surface for proper spinal alignment, so a hybrid topper may be the best option. Back sleepers also need good support to prevent the hips from sinking, while side sleepers benefit from materials that contour well around the hips and shoulders.
Thickness
Mattress toppers can vary in height, and the thicker they are, the more they change the feel of the mattress. That can be good or bad, depending on the state and feel of your current mattress, and it’s worth keeping in mind as you shop.
Price
A mattress topper can be an excellent alternative to splurging on a new mattress. Prices will vary depending on the brand, materials, and construction, but you can find good toppers that will suit most budgets.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the softest type of mattress topper?
The softest mattress topper is a matter of opinion. Some people will find lofty materials like down and down alternatives feel the softest, while others will prefer the marshmallow-y, sunken softness of materials like memory foam.
Can a mattress topper make a bed softer?
Absolutely! A well-constructed mattress topper with plush materials and sufficient height for your body type and sleep style is a great way to add a layer of softness to a firm mattress.
Is a plush top mattress good?
A mattress with a plush top can be a great pick depending on the sleeper. Comfort and support are subjective, and individual body types and sleep styles have a big impact on how a particular mattress feels. A plush top over supportive layers can be a dreamy combination, but some people may find they sink too deeply into the soft top to be comfortably or properly supported.
Our Final Take
A well-chosen mattress topper can be your ticket to a restful night, and plush toppers in particular are designed to add a dreamy layer of softness along with specific benefits. Sleep hot? The Nolah, Dreamfoam, and Birch toppers on our list are a great way to cool things down at night. For pressure relief, the Nolah and Viscosoft offer the kind of deep contouring you need. And if all you want is to sink into a soft cloud when you climb into bed, you can’t go wrong with Parachute or Brooklinen.
Remember to keep your body type and sleep preferences in mind as you shop for the best plush mattress topper. Sweet dreams!
