Puffy Mattress Topper Review
- Mattress Nerd Score: 4.5/5
- Materials: Bamboo and polyester with memory foam fill
- Sleep Trial: 101 nights
- Warranty: Lifetime warranty
The Nerd’s Take: The Puffy mattress topper is made with a bamboo and polyester blend that’s filled with memory foam that adjusts the firmness of your mattress for a more supportive night’s sleep. We think back and side sleepers will enjoy the pressure relief and contouring, while stomach sleepers may find it too soft.
Puffy Deluxe Mattress Topper
The Puffy Deluxe Mattress Topper adds a layer of luxurious comfort to your bed, available in firm or soft options for your particular needs.
Mattress Nerd Score
5.00 / 5
Read Full ReviewWho It’s Good For
- Side sleepers, back sleepers, and anyone seeking additional pressure relief
- People with allergies
- People who want to adjust the firmness of their mattress
- People who like the feel of memory foam
Who It’s Not Good For
- Stomach sleepers who might feel their hips sinking into the mattress
- Heavyweight sleepers who need more support
- People who don’t like the feel of memory foam
Feel
Exactly how cushiony or solid your Puffy mattress topper will feel depends entirely on the firmness level you select. Currently, there are two options: firm and soft. While both feature a memory foam filling and a lightweight bamboo-polyester blend cover, the soft mattress topper offers a plush feel. It’s designed to contour your body while providing support in pressure-sensitive areas like your hips and shoulders. Meanwhile, the firm version features a denser foam fill that offers extra support for those who prefer a sturdier surface.
Mattress Nerd Mattress Topper Scores
When we review a mattress topper, we look at six key areas to determine its overall performance: temperature control, alignment, motion isolation, material quality, care, and customer experience. Each area is given a score between 1-5, with 5 being the highest. Let’s see how the Puffy mattress topper held up.
Temperature Control: 4/5
This topper isn’t designed specifically for hot sleepers, but it does feature some naturally cooling materials. While memory foam has a reputation for trapping body heat, the bamboo and polyester fabrics used in the cover have breathable properties that’ll keep your bed’s airflow moving.
Alignment: 5/5
The Puffy mattress topper does an excellent job of keeping your spine in neutral alignment—especially if you’re a side or back sleeper. The soft version’s plush foam cushioning will cradle your body, while the firmer version provides a sturdier surface that’ll keep your hips and shoulders in line.
Motion Isolation: 4/5
There’s no denying that memory foam is one of the best mattress materials for motion isolation. While this topper isn’t specifically designed to reduce motion transfer, its memory foam fill should absorb most disturbances that come your way.
Quality of Materials: 5/5
From the breathable bamboo-polyester fabric to the memory foam fill, this mattress topper is designed with hypoallergenic materials. Plus, its durable construction will give you years of use.
Care: 4/5
Cleaning your Puffy topper is fairly easy. Its bamboo-polyester cover can easily be removed and tossed into the washing machine. While that’s a step up from spot-cleaning, other toppers allow you to machine wash the entire thing.
Customer Experience: 5/5
Not only does Puffy offer free shipping and free returns, but they also have an generous 101-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty. So if you’re unsatisfied with the feel of your mattress topper, you have plenty of time to return it without any financial risk.
Total Score: 4.5/5
Materials and Construction: What’s It Made of?
The Puffy mattress topper is constructed with a combination of memory foam and bamboo-polyester fabric. The memory foam fill conforms to your body and provides pressure relief in sensitive areas like your hips, neck, and shoulders. Meanwhile, the removable bamboo polyester cover is naturally cooling and breathable to alleviate any heat-trapping buildup.
All of the materials used are also hypoallergenic, so they won’t aggravate any allergies or skin sensitivities you or your sleeping buddy might have.
Pros/Cons
Pros
- Lightweight and breathable: The Puffy mattress topper isn’t overly heavy or dense, so it won’t weigh down your bed or inhibit airflow.
- Adjustable firmness: You can choose between soft and firm mattress toppers depending on your preferred level of support.
- Hypoallergenic materials: It’s made with allergy-safe fabrics and foam, so you don’t have to worry about skin irritations or dust mites.
- Lifetime warranty: It comes with a lifetime warranty for extra peace of mind.
Cons
- Cover-wash only: The Puffy mattress topper’s cover is removable, but you can’t machine-wash the entire thing.
- Too soft for stomach sleepers: While many will enjoy the plushness, it may be too soft for stomach sleepers.
Sizing, Pricing, and Policies
| Size | Weight | Dimensions | Price |
| Twin | 10 lbs for firm, 11 lbs for soft | 38” x 75” x 2.5” | $179 |
| Twin XL | 10.25 lbs for firm, 11.25 lbs for soft | 38” x 80” x 2.5” | $189 |
| Full | 14 lbs for firm, 15.3 lbs for soft | 54” x 75” x 2.5” | $209 |
| Queen | 16.5 lbs for firm, 17.6 lbs for soft | 60” x 80” x 2.5” | $229 |
| King | 22.2 lbs for firm, 22 lbs for soft | 76” x 80” x 2.5” | $249 |
| Cal King | 20 lbs for firm and 21.8 lbs for soft | 72” x 84” x 2.5” | $249 |
Shipping
Puffy offers free shipping and free returns within the 101-night sleep trial. Typically, toppers are delivered within 2 to 5 business days.
Trial Period and Warranty
When you purchase a Puffy mattress topper, you get to try it risk-free for 101 nights. However, you must try the mattress for at least 14 days before initiating a return—and the brand recommends trying it for a full 30 days to get used to the feel. Puffy also offers a lifetime warranty, so you can have peace of mind knowing that any manufacturing defects are fully covered.
FAQs
Is the Puffy mattress topper firm or soft?
The Puffy topper is available in both soft and firm models, so you can choose the one that fits your needs best. However, because it’s filled with memory foam, it is on the firmer side.
Do I need a mattress topper?
No, you don’t necessarily need a mattress topper. But they can be great for adding an extra layer of comfort, support, and protection over your existing mattress—especially if you’re not ready to replace your entire bed just yet.
Should I get a firm or soft mattress topper?
It depends on what you like! Firm toppers offer medium-firm support that relieves pressure while not letting your body sink down too far, while soft toppers provide plush cushioning that cradles your body for a cozier feel.
Should You Buy It?
The Puffy mattress topper is an excellent option for those who want a plush layer of support and cushioning without sacrificing breathability or making the bed too heavy. If you’re a side or back sleeper who needs a topper that can provide comfort and pressure relief, the Puffy mattress topper is definitely worth considering. However, stomach sleepers may be better off with something made of high-density foam, like the Saatva mattress topper.
Nerd Score Wrap Up
| Performance Factor | Out of 5 |
| Temperature Control | 4 |
| Alignment | 5 |
| Motion Isolation | 4 |
| Quality of Materials | 5 |
| Care | 4 |
| Customer Experience | 5 |
| Total Nerd Score | 4.5 |